DIY history for autocrats

Wishing a Happy New Year to all readers of this blog – thank you for reading.

It has been a depressing 2022 and the omens for 2023 don’t look great. I’m not completely convinced about the polycrisis notion, but for somebody in the UK the impact of events (the war), the cyclical downturn and the structural weaknesses of our economy and society (where to start?) make for a bleak start to the year.

So how better to begin my reading, amid the relaxing mayhem and death of detective fiction (and a quick re-read of The Wealth of Nations to decide whether I have anything to say in an upcoming Adam Smith workshop), than Katie Stallard’s Dancing on Bones? A journalist, the author has reported for years from Russia, China and North Korea. The book was published just as Russia invaded Ukraine, so doesn’t reflect the most recent events, but it starts in Ukraine in 2014, with the initial invasion of Crimea. The book is a reflection on how these autocrats – Xi , Putin and the Kims – use history (I should write ‘history’) to cement their hold on power. In particular, it describes how in each case history has been rewritten into myth, with a specific conflict turned into a regime founding story. I hadn’t known that the USSR used not to make such a big deal of World War 2, that China’s memorial days were even more recently introduced, or indeed that the successive Kims simply invented the account of the Korean war that is taught to all North Korean subjects from kindergarten on.

It is a bit disconcerting to read of the events of 1989 told as distant history – I’m old enough to have super-clear memories of watching the TV reports from East Germany, from Prague, from Romania in late 1989, and in one of my jobs immersed myself in the detail of perestroika to interpret the USSR economy.

The most engaging parts of the book are those told from direct experience, the reportage, not surprisingly. Even so, I learned things I hadn’t known – especially about N Korea – and it’s very well written. It’s a good complement to the excellent Strongmen by Ruth Ben-Ghiat (I haven’t read Gideon Rachman’s The Age of the Strongman). Let’s hope 2023 turns into a bad year for autocrats.



10 thoughts on “DIY history for autocrats

  1. Pingback: History of DIY for autocrats | The Enlightened Economist - See3in News

  2. As someone who grew up in the Soviet Union, I can tell you that WW2 (or the Great Patriotic War as it was called) was absolutely a big deal during communist times. That makes me question how accurate this book is. I’ve never been in Putin’s Russia, so I don’t know how he changed things.

    • She doesn’t say it wasn’t a big deal – rather, that it took a few years after the end of the war for that to start, and that Putin has dialed it up enormously. So you make too big a leap in questioning the accuracy book on the basis of a very short review.

  3. Pingback: Historia del bricolaje para autócratas | El economista ilustrado - A7 news

  4. Pingback: DIY historical past for autocrats | The Enlightened Economist - CrediReview

  5. I don’t know if there’s an actual book about how national myths are built. But classic studies of the rise of Nazi power cite Bismarck as the creator of an explicit national myth to unite Germany based on repelling the Romans 9 AD at Teutoburg Forest, an event forgotten by German historians until B revived it in the 19th c.
    There’s also the electrifying and little known tale of how the aging Ben-Gurion noted that the 1961 televised trial of Eichmann drew nearly every viewer in Israel. He decided to create a national myth based on the Nazi genocide as he was in need of a campaign boost. Previously, Israelis were doughty atheists socialists who sneered at European Jews’ dreams of assimilation, as well as teleologies of sacrifice for the foundation of Israel and the coming of the Messiah. They mistreated and ignored survivors of the genocide who made it to Israel. Overnight pivot by Ben Gurion — a cracking story written by Idith Zertal, and published, I think, by Cambridge.
    Good examples of the theory one man changes history.

  6. Pingback: DIY historical past for autocrats | The Enlightened Economist - Dinero Post

  7. Pingback: DIY Story for Autocrats | The Illuminated Economist - News-dojpro

  8. Pingback: DIY history for autocrats | The Enlightened Economist - Kimaura

Comments are closed.