Needed: elasticity of mind

I just read for the first time since the late 1970s Keynes’s essay [amazon_link id=”B005E8FUT4″ target=”_blank” ]How to Pay for the War[/amazon_link], published in February 1940 on the basis of two Times articles of November 1939. (It’s included in my 1972 RES/Macmillan edition of [amazon_link id=”0230249574″ target=”_blank” ]Essays in Persuasion[/amazon_link].)

My immediate interest was the part this essay played in the development of official national output figures in order to measure the economy’s productive capacity: Keynes’s frustration at needing to rely on the private estimates recently published by [amazon_link id=”0714612162″ target=”_blank” ]Colin Clark[/amazon_link] is evident.

[amazon_image id=”0714612162″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]National Income and Outlay[/amazon_image]

However, I’m struck – awed – by the clarity of Keynes’s overview of the way the war economy needed to be managed. The ability to step back from small parts of a problem to see the whole is rare. In this case, it involved understanding that a different way of thinking was required, so greatly had the context changed. Keynes wrote:

“We have become so accustomed to the problem of unemployment and excess resources that it requires some elasticity of mind to adapt our behaviour to the problem of full employment and of resources which are no longer adequate to supply our needs.”

Elasticity of mind – a lovely phrase for a capacity so few of us have.

This question of changed context is surely relevant to today’s macro policy questions. It often seems to me that the dispute between different camps is a matter of disagreement about context. In other words, they disagree about the nature of the most pressing problem. I’ve always been very taken with the way Edmond Malinvaud set this out explicitly in [amazon_link id=”063117690X” target=”_blank” ]The Theory of Unemployment Reconsidered[/amazon_link], although I don’t think his specific ’70s framework fits the kind of open economy and financialised world we have now.

[amazon_image id=”B005E8FUT4″ link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]How to pay for the war : a radical plan for the chancellor of the exchequer / by John Maynard Keynes[/amazon_image]

One thought on “Needed: elasticity of mind

  1. “How to pay for the war”

    Exactly where we are today!

    We’ve been at war since the beginning of the ’90s and governments have been hard at work covering up the cost ever since

    That’s why we are basically bankrupt and have no money to pay for the needs of our citizens in health, housing or infrastructure

Comments are closed.